A blog about television by TIME’s TV critic James Poniewozik.

Heroeswatch: Creature of Light, Creature of Darkness

Still on vacation, but I was watching Heroes and had to tell this to someone: the bit with the guy killing the grass radiating around him in a concentric circle? Totally ripped off from Carnivale, no? (Look around the 7:00 mark on that clip.) Granted, it doesn't seem like the grim-looking dude in question is planning on healing anyone, Ben Hawkins-style, but still. The effect was much cooler when they did it with a cornfield, I think. (Just like Heroes, Carnivale was one of those shows I liked much better for the story than the writing--but I watched every episode anyway.)

Now granted, I'm much more familiar with TV sci-fi/fantasy than with comix, so for all I know, Heroes steals much more blatantly from comic books all the time. [Update: Though if they've victimized Stan Lee, he must forgive them, judging by the cameo.] Hell, maybe Carnivale did, too. Any of our Heroes / comic geeks care to weigh in? Did Clea have anything to do with this?

[Update #2: Almost forgot it was Someone! Will! Die! night. I'll leave the Comments open as a remembrance book for Simone.]

  • Print
  • Comment
Comments (3)
Post a Comment »
  • 1

    James,

    I don't know about Carnivale but that grave scene was pure comic book imagery. So was the sock drawer of introduction but this is a show about 'superheroes' and the wacky camera angles they get themselves into.

    What struck me as VERY comic bookish was the meeting of the anti-HRG Heroes in the cemetary, right down to the spooky! dramatic! lighting. I could just see Jeph Loeb painting that whole scene out in a duo-tone of blue and purple.

    As for Simone, I'm kind of glad she died. She had Gwen Stacey (Spiderman's first girlfriend/lost love) written all over her. I do like how the writers used her to drive a wedge between Hunky Painter Guy and the Exploding Nurse. The writers have done (IMO your Emminence) a good job of building Peter up as the Cyclops-goody-two-shoes-uber-boy-scout of the Heroes and now he'll have to deal with the fact that he's not only responsible for possibly leveling Manhatten but getting his proto-girlfriend killed.

    Enjoy your vacation!

  • 2

    Heroes does draw tremendously on comic books. Much of it is fairly subtle, so it's something that a non-comic reader/afficiando would really catch, but it is there.

    (I actually disturbed my roommate because I was actually screaming at the television during the scene were future-Hiro meets current-Peter on the train. I was screaming something along the lines of 'DAYS OF FUTURE PAST! DAYS OF FUTURE PAST!')

  • 3

    Its too bad the painter didn't paint Simone's death in order to avoid it occuring. Her death was a contrived tragedy. Peter couldn't do anything to prevent her from being shot? He seems like a goody two shoes but his temper and forced plot devicing is kinda annoying.

Add Your Comment:

You must be logged in to post a comment.
Tuned In Daily E-mail

Get e-mail updates from TIME's Tuned In in your inbox and never miss a day.

Quotes of the Day »

Get & Share
DEBI HEISS, on Ohio's execution of 51-year-old Kenneth Biros; Heiss's sister Tami was a victim of Biros, and the family applauded as the time of death was announced. It was the nation's first execution by a single injection rather than the three-drug process