A blog about television by TIME’s TV critic James Poniewozik.

Lostwatch: Guerrillas in the Myst

SPOILER ALERT: If you haven't watched last night's Lost, don't cross the invisible threshold below, unless you want blood to spurt out of your ears.

claireblackhair.jpg
ABC/MARIO PEREZ

Lostwatch fans--yes, both of you--are probably wondering about now why I've fallen asleep on the job. Technical problems, involving time.com, or our blog-hosting company, or an electromagnetic pulse, I'm really not sure what, have kept me from logging in until just now.

Anyway, I'm happy. It's easy to give up the praise to Lost episodes with memorable standalone plots--the Tailies episode, Desmond's unstuck-in-time flashback--but shows like last night's, which just plug ahead on the serial story, are the essence of the series.

Yes, there were implausibilities (Desmond catching a bird with his hands, a sonic barracks-defense system). I don't really care. "Par Avion" showed that, while it may take its sweet time, Lost is not simply letting threads drop forever. First, the hints turned out to be true that Claire is Jack's half-sister. (As well as a former quasi-Goth girl.) Second, we got another indication of the mysterious "Him" behind the Others and confirmation--if we can believe it--that Ben is not the Others' ultimate leader. (The theory that Ben is actually Him has persisted even though Ben referred to Him last year in his Fake Henry Gale days last season.)

The episode, with the Strike Team trying to get past the barracks' perimeter, also reminded me of something that I meant to make more of in my Lost feature last fall if I'd had the room: that the best way to understand Lost's structure is to look at it as a computer game, specifically one like Myst. You are on an island that's both serenely beautiful and hostile; there is a series of challenges, the solving of which opens new "areas" but present further mysteries; there is a mythology and history to the island that unravels itself as you play; and as in a videogame--and I'm stealing this idea from Steven Johnson and probably others--you have to discover the "rules" of this game in the process of playing it.

Other bits:

* Not so much comic relief last night, but I got a charge out of the Sayid-Locke dynamic, as they increasingly tussle over leadership. Sayid to Locke, on the reliability of the electrical map: "It's certainly not as infallible as the magical carvings on your stick." And a nice what's-his-game moment about Locke's swiping the C4, which he had claimed not to know was in Bakunin's lair. Maybe he's not a dumb as he's been playing at lately.

* If you're sending a note to the world by birdmail, might you not want to focus a little less on the bringing-new-life-into-the-world business and maybe a little more on the crazy-Utopian-scientists-are-trying-to-kill-us business? I mean, I know it sounds like a tall tale, but isn't there the chance that people in the outside world would be able to verify the existence of DHARMA?

* Finally: football? I had the Others pegged as soccer people.

  • Print
  • Comment
Comments (4)
Post a Comment »
  • 1

    James,

    There was some great comedy last night - I'm thinking specifically of Locke's great line (paraphrased because I don't remember it exactly now) - "Sure, I really knew that the Others had a sonic death fence."

    Questions:
    1. Weird that Claire worked at a tattoo/earring parlor, but has no tattoos, isn't it? And that Jack works white-collar as a doctor but has tattoos?
    2. Is it just me, or is Jack's dad one of the most interesting characters on the show?
    3. Okay, so Sayid, Kate, Locke and Rousseau got into the sonic death fence, but how are they going to get out? Not easy to jump up and grab that tree they used to get in...
    4. Is Rousseau an Other? I know we think she isn't, but did you notice that SHE was the one who cut off Bakunin before he could reveal that Locke had been paralyzed?

  • 2

    It is about time you posted James. I was trying to find the Time management's e-mail address to let them know you were asleep at the wheel. :)

    My boss who has been a waivering fan all season long felt that it was one of the best episodes this season. It did finally progress the story along nicely.

    Chad, I also wondered why she didn't have any tattoos.

    They will get out the same way they got in. Cut down a tree on the other side and climb out. You would think that they would precut it for a quick getaway though.

    Rousseau an Other? Time will tell.

    Question....can the migratory birds escape the island. The tag means nothing. They may have flown in and can't fly out. Also, it would have been interesting to see if the tag had a Dharma logo on it.

    I'm pumped about next week being Locke's wheelchair story.

  • 3

    That last scene with Jack running, not to help his friends but to catch the pass from QB Tom was a nice piece of direction, as was the "WTF" look on Kate's face.

    I'm sure Sayid will be able to find the "turn security system off HERE" switch... he's good at that, plus, he's got an all-things-electrical map.

  • 4

    About the note: writing it on paper probably not the best idea when it's attached to waterfowl. Once that bird gets hungry and it lands on the water, the note is going to fall apart.

    Locke doesn't want to leave the island. That's why he blew up the station and took the C4--just in case there's any other communication device that needs exploding.

Add Your Comment:

You must be logged in to post a comment.
Tuned In Daily E-mail

Get e-mail updates from TIME's Tuned In in your inbox and never miss a day.

Quotes of the Day »

Get & Share
DEBI HEISS, on Ohio's execution of 51-year-old Kenneth Biros; Heiss's sister Tami was a victim of Biros, and the family applauded as the time of death was announced. It was the nation's first execution by a single injection rather than the three-drug process