A blog about television by TIME’s TV critic James Poniewozik.

Lostwatch: The Tribe Has Spoken

lostpig.jpg
MARIO PEREZ/ABC

Oceanic Airlines flight 815 crashed in September 2004. At that point, we were several seasons in to the run of Survivor. And yet, amid all the pop-culture references of Lost, no one breathes a word about the show. Come on! Sawyer, of all people, would be calling Hurley "Richard Hatch" constantly.

But last night Lost--which, after all, originated with Lloyd Braun's idea of making a fictional Survivor as a drama--became an episode of Survivor. There was an (admittedly fictitious) banishment vote. There was an actual banishment, or, rather, the Others banished themselves, sans Juliet. Sawyer went out and caught a fish to prove he was pulling his weight around camp. There was one of those Mark Burnett swap gimmicks, as one from our tribe (Locke) got exchanged for one of theirs (Juliet). There was a pig roast. I'm surprised nobody won a Pontiac Aztek.

Seriously, a solid episode from a show that seems to have a good head of narrative momentum. It probably deserves a serious unpacking, but I'm still on "vacation," so I'm just going to unload a round of bullet points into you:

* Is Locke an Other now? Is he just out to get answers / closure from his produced-from-the-magic-box father? Either seems plausible: as we saw in his first flashback this season, he's definitely susceptible to cultish mumbo-jumbo. And for once, it seemed to make sense not to give the answer, since it's definitely in Locke's character to keep his own counsel.

* So Kate and Juliet get handcuffed together... and get their t-shirts soaked in a sudden downpour... and fall into a mud pit? What, was there no pool of Jell-O available? Nice nugget we got there, that the Others don't control the monster--"We don't know what it is, but we know it doesn't like our fences"--as well as the code Juliet entered to activate the security fence: did I catch 6-2-3 in the number sequence? (As in 15... 16... 23...)

* The rapid-fire sound that accompanied the light when the monster spied Kate and Juliet: did it sound like gunfire? or photography?

* An interesting side effect of bringing Locke's dad into the story: suddenly, things we learn in the flashbacks may have more direct bearing on the present-day story, such as this flashback, which brought Kate together with Sawyer's ex, and, perhaps, put Kate on the road to Tallahassee.

* "Just for today, they can eat boar, laugh and forget that they're totally screwed." Sawyer's position as "temporary leader" promises an interesting dynamic now that Jack has returned, having nearly gotten a ticket home from their mortal enemies. But not nearly as interesting as Sayid going Jack Bauer on Juliet for information next week. (Until, I'm guessing, Jack breaks up the party seconds before Juliet is about to spill something vital.)

The floor's open to your guesses as to the Others' whereabouts. Exile Island?

  • Print
  • Comment
Comments (6)
Post a Comment »
  • 1

    I'm wondering if we're building to a battle between faith representented by the cultish Others, plus Locke, now, apparently, and science/rationality/cold-hearted reality as represented by the Losties, who include doctors (Jack & Juliet, as well as MIA dentist Bernard), and "criminals/conmen" who deal in the cold, hard world of reality (Kate, Sawyer, Jin, and Sayid). I'm still trying to fit Hurley (who seems more or less caught in between), Charlie (who's had his moments in "reality" with drug addiction, but also moments of "faith" like building the church), Sun, Rose (definitely more in the faith camp) and Claire (may have caused her mother's death, but also listened to a psychic regarding her child so she has faith).

    And if the battle is between actual faith and reason/science camps, what is the significance of it? Why does it matter? And who wins?

    I go back to what Locke said to Ben - the Others weren't "surviving" the same way the Losties were: they were in houses, in camps, with food provided for them and no need to live off the island and fend for themselves. Being forced to leave their camp (for the other island?) and without a means to travel to and from the outside world might be disastrous to their faith-based, right-wrong system....

  • 2

    Wow! Great episode. And yes, I would have enjoyed a jello pit. It was interesting to see Sawyer get conned by Hurley. Juliet always comes across as a shrinking violet. Geez, did she kick Kate's butt or what. I see a future flashback showing how she eventually toughened up. Yes, she is an other......but, is she an other? What happened during Jack's captivity that we didn't see that makes him trust her so much. It was cool seeing Sawyer's girlfriend/mark with Kate and finding out she is pregnant. Do you think that in the end, everyone will dicover their unknown connections?

  • 3

    Tobias,

    Nope. Jeff Jensen over on Entertainment Weekly (ew.com) mentioned it too....

  • 4

    Check out the LOST DIARY on tmz.com - its funny and actually covers a lot

  • 5

    My loyalties lie with Tuned In(although EW apparently has a good review as well)

  • 6

    I realize we are supposed to suspend reality in TV land, but a thought occured to me yesterday. Locke, Kate and Sayid climbed over the fence. You'd think a cloud of smoke hitting and object would go around it any way it can.....you know, being smoke and all. Why doesn't it simply go over the top of the sonic fence?

Add Your Comment:

You must be logged in to post a comment.
Tuned In Daily E-mail

Get e-mail updates from TIME's Tuned In in your inbox and never miss a day.

Quotes of the Day »

Get & Share
ANONYMOUS PHOTOGRAPHER, on taking pictures of royals, which Queen Elizabeth recently warned U.K. newspapers about; Prince Edward was eventually cleared of animal cruelty after photos surfaced of him reprimanding his dogs