A blog about television by TIME’s TV critic James Poniewozik.

Lostwatch: Baby Love

SPOILER ALERT: If you haven't watched last night's Lost yet, drink this glass of orange juice...

julietclaire.jpg

ABC/ MARIO PEREZ

Oh, Juliet! You naughty girl! I had been worried that last night's Lost was going to try to win us over to Juliet's side, making her a sympathetic new member of the gang immediately. Fortunately, the writers realized that the audience is more Sayid than Jack--more inclined to suspect than to trust--and revealed that she is in fact a mole. (Speaking of Sayid, Sawyer et al. as audience surrogates, could Jack's line, "Eventually, they're going to need some answers," have been more of a meta comment?)

In all another solid episode, and it stood out for one particular reason: for once, the flashback was as interesting or more so than the present-day storyline. Or rather, it naturally connected to and advanced the present-day storyline. I had a few quibbles. (A disease-inducing "implant" in Claire? That's barely more plausible than Sawyer's booby-trapped pacemaker, which the writers sensibly revealed was phony.)

But there was a good question-to-answer ratio, though I'm sure there will be complaints. It's getting harder, I think, to make the case that the show's producers have been making everything up as they go along, given the number of payoffs from the first and second seasons we've been seeing recently. (Last night, the explanation[s] for Ethan's nighttime visits to Claire.) I'm not saying they had five years of the show drafted out to the letter, but you can't convince me that they didn't have a strong sense from the get-go of what was going on on the island and why.

I know that Others-centric episodes bore some people, including the formidable Alan Sepinwall. But I love them; I love, especially, how they teeter between being invincible manipulators and a humdrum bureaucracy, with interoffice politics, romances (Goodwin was getting it on with Juliet! Score, dude!) and annoying coworkers. ("He never leaves his walkie on," Ben grouses about Mikhail.) They're half-cult, half-dysfunctional nonprofit organization--two institutions with considerable overlap in the personality types they attract.

So we know that the Others are having some self-perpetuation problems. What's maybe more interesting is that Juliet told the castaways that too, consistent with Ben's longtime strategy of mixing in a certain measure of truth with his mindgames and deceptions. And we got another hint at the Others' all-powerful "Jacob," who may or may not be "Him." Any chance we meet him in the season finale? I'm taking bets.

It also looks like Jack is starting to take over Locke's second-season role as the sucker, blinded by his will to believe what he wants to believe. And since Lost loves to polar-reverse the situations of the Man of Science and the Man of Faith, does that mean that Locke--rather than being a turncoat--had something up his sleeve in going with the Others? We've seen that--because he was able to get the island healing that Ben couldn't--he's the one character who's truly able to get under Ben's skin. Could he be the guy who can out-Ben Ben?

Who knows? But, as Ben told Juliet: see you in a week.

  • Print
  • Comment
Comments (2)
Post a Comment »
  • 1

    Best episode of the season, by far.

    As for Jack being a "sucker," I'm going to disagree with you, James. Something about his explanation to Kate that he "kept his head down" while being with the Others sounds fishy. Could Jack be manipulating Juliet - making her think that he completely trusts her but secretly keeping his eye on her? Could Jack be the one out-Ben-ing both Ben AND Juliet?

    Another thought came to me too, last night - maybe Charlie is an Other, now, brainwashed or switched to the side of evil. Remember season 1 - he was found strangled in a tree, but miraculously lived. He shot Ethan (reminiscent of what Mikhail did to Ms. Klu, to prevent her from talking). He's the one who went after Aaron with Sayid when he was kidnapped (needs to keep an eye on the kid), and he's the one who convincingly was able to "fake" a kipnapping by Sun of the Others and ensure Sawyer, the castaway least likely to hunt after the Others, kept the guns. He's the one who walked into the Ocean with Aaron (fighing the brainwashing? Cultish baptism?), he's the one sleeping nearest to Claire, he's the one who got her the serum, he's the one who is now closest to her and perhaps able to "activate" the implant.

    And remember, Desmond only seems to be having visions about Charlie as a result of the purple-sky hatch implosion. Could it be the island/Others effecting Desmond, making him Charlie's (unwitting) caretaker to ensure Charlie's mission succeeds (i.e. death could compromise the Others' plans)?

    The more I think about this, the more I like the theory that Charlie may be an Other, or affiliated with them, or somehow evil. I think it's a HUGE game-change in the series, and one most people would NEVER see coming.

  • 2

    Chad,

    I'm impressed. Good points about Charlie that I had not considered. Could the "time" aspect of the island be what is causing the problems with pregnancies starting at conception?

    It was a great episode. Best of all, we got to see Juliet's hot backside!!! Woot!!! I so don't want her to be a bad guy.

Add Your Comment:

You must be logged in to post a comment.
Tuned In Daily E-mail

Get e-mail updates from TIME's Tuned In in your inbox and never miss a day.

Quotes of the Day »

Get & Share
DEBI HEISS, on Ohio's execution of 51-year-old Kenneth Biros; Heiss's sister Tami was a victim of Biros, and the family applauded as the time of death was announced. It was the nation's first execution by a single injection rather than the three-drug process