A blog about television by TIME’s TV critic James Poniewozik.

The Morning After: Murder, You Wrote

womens_murder_1012.jpg
DANNY FELD / ABC

Discussion time for any and all weekend TV. For instance: Is anyone still watching Moonlight? For another instance: It occurred to me after the fact that I'd never gotten around to doing a review for Women's Murder Club Friday night on ABC, which, believe me, was probably best for all of us. So I thought I'd crowdsource that one out this morning. Your thoughts? If there are no comments, we'll consider that a review in itself.

  • Print
  • Comment
Comments (6)
Post a Comment »
  • 1

    I was really looking forward to this show, because I love women and I love murder and, while I don't LOVE clubs, I don't dislike them either. I figured this show was a can't-miss proposition.

    Well, it missed.

  • 2

    Time for my weekly praise session for Friday Night Lights. Let's go to the highlights:

    - Connie Britton. Seriously, Emmy voters - WHAT were you THINKING? They should just close nominations for Best Actress, because Britton in this season's first TWO episodes has won the award. She's SOOOO phenomenal.

    - The Matt-Julie breakup. Arguably the most "real" breakup I've ever seen on television - no high drama, and you can tell Julie's heart is still somewhat devoted to Matt, but they're in high school. In other words, they make mistakes, fall in and out of love quickly, and in general don't necessarily stay together.

    - Lyla and Riggins. Awesome chemistry, and Riggin's hidden heart of gold came out when helping Lyla with Buddy.

    - Tyra and Landry. Lots of controversy to this storyline, but the tone of Friday's episode got back to FNL's standards. And I have a feeling the repercussions will be quite real for this storyline.

    - Landry's dad is AGENT PIERCE? Awesome! (Coincidentally, could the two of them look any MORE like father and son?)

    This show just screams excellence. Looks like the ratings slipped a little bit, but hopefully it's staying strong enough for NBC to keep it on the air on Friday nights. I know I'll keep tuning in...

  • 3

    I was trying to give Moonlight a chance, I really was...vampire PI? You mean like Angel? Can't miss...well, live and learn I suppose. I plan on giving it another week to improve, but I may keep it on my record list just to watch the train wreck at full speed.

  • 4

    John, Farner....allow me to introduce you to Friday Night Lights. You can thank me later...

  • 5

    I didn't even watch the whole pilot of Moonlight. It was horrible!

    Women's Murder Club was definitely disappointing! I will check out another episode and then decide if I'm giving up or not.

  • 6

    I watched Womens Murder Club for relationship reasons. It had many, many flaws, but the worst one was when the writers attempted to inject a personal side to the characters, which went something like this:

    Character 1: We must catch this killer! It's urgent!
    Character 2: I agree, it's our top priority!
    Character 1: So, are you getting back together with Tom?

    A bit jarring.

    Also, in case anyone was wondering, Life Is Wild is ungood. It's Little House on the Prairie with the Olesons as the protagonists.

Add Your Comment:

You must be logged in to post a comment.
Tuned In Daily E-mail

Get e-mail updates from TIME's Tuned In in your inbox and never miss a day.

Quotes of the Day »

Get & Share
DEBI HEISS, on Ohio's execution of 51-year-old Kenneth Biros; Heiss's sister Tami was a victim of Biros, and the family applauded as the time of death was announced. It was the nation's first execution by a single injection rather than the three-drug process