A blog about television by TIME’s TV critic James Poniewozik.

Friday Night Lights Watch: Back So Soon?

taylor_buddy.jpg
NBC Photo: Bill Records

Well, that was fast. For all the attention that's gone to the Tyra-Landry stalker-killing subplot, I'm more bothered by how quickly Jason Katims decided to undo Coach Taylor's abandonment of the Panthers to coach college ball. Yeah, I realize this is TV; yeah, I realize that everyone expected that somewhere, somehow, Taylor was going to be back in Dillon, most likely before the season was over. But four weeks in? Even The Office managed to have Jim stick it out in Stamford longer than that.

On the plus side, I'm feeling better about Landry's storyline. Distracting as it may have been, it's provided Jesse Plemons with some fine, deserved scenes, notably the one of him sweating it out in church this week. It's been said before but is worth repeating: it's refreshing--even, or especially, to a nonreligious viewer like me--to see how well this show works faith in, neither pandering to it nor denigrating it, but simply showing it as a powerful part of life. What's good or bad about it, whether it injures you or sustains you, depends on what you do with it. It's God's football.

Likewise, I find Lyla a lot more interesting this season having found God--and now, trying to figure out what to do with him--than agonizing between Riggins and Street. (Speaking of her emerging story with the convict she's trying to help, I'm glad to see that this season seems to be doing more to acknowledge that there are Hispanics in Texas, not that they were totally absent last year. It might be nice also to see some that aren't convicts or employees--though as the Saracens' home health-care aide made a point of stressing, she's not a maid.)

It looks like Lyla will be pulled back into Riggins' and Street's orbit again next week, as Tim calls on her to talk Tim out of his experimental therapy--after that gripping karaoke scene in which Riggins realized how far gone and desperate his friend was. It looks like, a month into the season, FNL has set the pieces in place for its second-season storylines, and--if the show survives long enough--next week we'll start seeing how well their plans play out.

I just hope that, with both the Coach and the Tyra-Landry storylines, the show isn't just wiping the slate clean and hoping we forget both stories ever happened. So far I have faith that it won't (Taylor's embittered replacement is still out there, as is Landry's watch). FNL is too good a show to just forget anything.

  • Print
  • Comment
Comments (5)
Post a Comment »
  • 1

    Remember that Season 1 would have ended in December (in tv time) with the State Championship game. So in tv time, Coach would have been gone 8 or 9 months.

  • 2

    I agree with your review, James, but I gotta admit - it's nice to have Coach back in Dillon.

    But his return wasn't seamless (the scene with the fired coach was intense, and you know that we'll be seeing him again on the opposing sideline), and to a large degree, the fired coach's regime did a bunch of damage. This isn't the united Dillon Panthers we saw at the end of last season - it has guys with big egos (Smash), guys with little confidence (Saracen, for now), guys who have lost their direction (Riggins), and players without talent (sorry Landry). I'm looking forward to the inevitably awesome scenes where Coach Taylor has to pull these guys back together as a unified team.

    Add in the damage his departure did to his family, which he still needs to put in some work rebuilding, and we're set up to have our favorite storylines (the Taylor household, and the team) firing on all cylinders soon enough.

    As for Tyra-Landry, I'm liking what this storyline is doing in giving Tyra something to do (too often last year she was just the "loose" girl without focus - now she seems to be getting her life in order, ironically, by being pulled so much closer to Landry due to this horrible accident), as well as making Landry more than comedic fodder (although we could use some good old Saracen-Landry scenes, or another Crucifictorious set). And let's not forget Agent Aaron Pierce as Landry's dad....arguably the best casting decision on television this season, non-Kristen Bell on Heroes division.

  • 3

    It's inevitable in a high school show, but what drives me nuts is suspension of reality on the grade that these kids are in. I thought Street was the prep stud going to Notre Dame and Riggins was his best friend since they were kids. All of a sudden Riggens is back for another year.

    A high school team that wins the Texas state championship and returns all of its key players would be tops in the nation not losing games.

    Sarasen punching Smash was a joke also. The entire year he dealt with his dad leaving, his grandma, becoming QB1 and did not break. Smash getting attention sends him over the top? Nah.

  • 4

    Agent Aaron Pierce! Fabulous, Chaddogg. I knew he looked familiar. What are there, about 25 working actors in Hollywood? I watch more TV shows where I'm suddenly distracted by seeing someone from another show and trying to figure out who they are. Wait, freeze frame! Roll back! That neighbor on The Riches! That's Kaitlin Olson from It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia! And yo, there she is again on Curb Your Enthusiasm from a week ago! There's a game in there that could be every bit as good as Six Degrees of Kevin Bacon. But, to get back on the subject--one of the things I actually like best about FNL is that, besides Coach and his wife, pretty much everybody is completely new to me. And perfectly cast, too.

  • 5

    I don't think there is anyway we could have gone longer without Coach Taylor. He is the heart and soul of the show. The Office had Michael and Dwight to carry the action in Scranton while Jim dealt with his new office. FNL only has Riggins to carry the show while Taylor is absentee. The only problem with that is that it doesn't allow us to get into the adult issues that made the first season deep and not just another high school drama. Taylor interacting with the community as a surrogate father (since he's the coach) provides some of the best FNL moments. The old coach still being out there and Landry's watch still floating around give us some nice loose ends. Plus, now Julie will have to fight to get Matt back...could be interesting.

Add Your Comment:

You must be logged in to post a comment.
Tuned In Daily E-mail

Get e-mail updates from TIME's Tuned In in your inbox and never miss a day.

Quotes of the Day »

Get & Share
DEBI HEISS, on Ohio's execution of 51-year-old Kenneth Biros; Heiss's sister Tami was a victim of Biros, and the family applauded as the time of death was announced. It was the nation's first execution by a single injection rather than the three-drug process