A blog about television by TIME’s TV critic James Poniewozik.

TV Tonight: Doctors, with Borders

 

ABC

ABC

The midseason is getting under way in earnest, with more primetime debuts tonight:

 

* On ABC, Scrubs returns for a possibly-last season on a new network. I'll admit that I haven't followed the show closely for a couple of years, so I'll take other critics at their word when they say that the new episodes represent a return to the show's early years on NBC. For my part, I still see a very funny show that overrelies on fantasy sequence gags and doesn't always pull off the transition between characters-as-cartoons and characters-as-people. Tonight gives us the debut of Courteney Cox, whose chief mode as an actress, from Friends to FX's Dirt, is to seem like she's just given someone a fake compliment. Somehow that manages to work in this role. Everytime I watch Scrubs, I laugh and wonder why I don't watch more often—yet I don't actually get around to watching more often. 

* In FX doctor news, Nip/Tuck returns with a premiere that (for now) steps back from the Hollywood-satire extremes that put me off last season and refocuses on the central characters of Sean and Christian. I haven't really loved Nip/Tuck since season 3, but I'm going to give it another chance. 

* And back on ABC, we get the debut of Homeland Security USA, a reality show from Big Brother's Arnold Shapiro about the government employees who oversee border crossings and airport entry points. Have the DHS's eagle eyes prevented another 9/11? I don't know, and considering that DHS's eagle eyes were allowed to vet and approve this series before air, I wouldn't depend on this show to tell you. In the debut episode we do see the affable agents stopping a Swiss belly dancer from entering the country without a work visa; scanning mail for barbecued bat and tainted food that "could cause illness, and death!"; and seizing narcotics, including over 100 pounds of marijuana at a border crossing, a crime so heinous the driver gets three years' probation.

As for the actual protection from terrorism, that's mostly left implied by the voiceover and the interviews. When a radiation alarm goes off at a checkpoint, for instance, the show allows a DHS employee to explain that these could be the materials for a "dirty bomb." The fact that a dirty bomb is not the same as a nuke, and that it presents relatively little threat to life (as opposed to property), is left implicit: "It only takes a little radiation," he says, "to make something that can scare a lot of people."

Or you can have ABC scare them for you.

  • Print
  • Comment
Comments (4)
Post a Comment »
  • 1

    I'm a longtime Scrubs fan, but the last couple seasons didn't really do it for me so I'll probably Tivo this and watch it like three weeks from now. It kind of bothers me that the one time a doomed series changes networks and finds new life, it's a show that's already run its course and become stale, instead of deserving series like Arrested Development or Pushing Daisies. I know it's because Scrubs was an ABC/Touchstone production from the beginning, but the last few seasons didn't exactly inspire me to start a Save Scrubs campaign.

    And I don't want to make light of terrorism or the good people of Homeland Security, but I think I could probably deal with a little bit of radiation if it came with Swiss belly dancers and bushels of marijuana.

  • 2

    I'm a longtime Scrubs fan, but the last couple seasons didn't really do it for me so I'll probably Tivo this and watch it like three weeks from now. It kind of bothers me that the one time a doomed series changes networks and finds new life, it's a show that's already run its course and become stale, instead of deserving series like Arrested Development or Pushing Daisies. I know it's because Scrubs was an ABC/Touchstone production from the beginning, but the last few seasons didn't exactly inspire me to start a Save Scrubs campaign.

    And I don't want to make light of terrorism or the good people of Homeland Security, but I think I could probably deal with a little bit of radiation getting across the border if it came with Swiss belly dancers and bushels of marijuana.

  • 3

    (Sorry for the double post. It's been a while.)

  • 4

    James - you never seem to give much attention to Biggest Loser, which combines freak show with real emotion in a strangely powerful way. It's mean and really sweet at the same time, somehow. Anyway, it had its debut last night, does some truly odd product placements and seems to be one of NBC's few bright spots. How come you don't love this?

Add Your Comment:

You must be logged in to post a comment.
Tuned In Daily E-mail

Get e-mail updates from TIME's Tuned In in your inbox and never miss a day.

Quotes of the Day »

Get & Share
DEBI HEISS, on Ohio's execution of 51-year-old Kenneth Biros; Heiss's sister Tami was a victim of Biros, and the family applauded as the time of death was announced. It was the nation's first execution by a single injection rather than the three-drug process