A blog about television by TIME’s TV critic James Poniewozik.

Dead Tree Alert: In Treatment Returns

HBO

HBO

In this week's print TIME, I review season 2 of In Treatment, which returns this Sunday and which (having seen four weeks so far) I like better than the first: 

 

By the time Paul Weston (Gabriel Byrne) sits down for a session with his own therapist, Gina (Dianne Wiest), he has had a long week. He's been served with a subpoena in a lawsuit stemming from a former patient. On top of that, he's going through a divorce and has uprooted himself from suburban Maryland to Brooklyn, N.Y., where he's started a new practice. "Oh," Gina says cheerfully, "some new problems to listen to." Wearily, Paul answers, "There are no new problems."

In one sense, he is absolutely right. Season 2 of HBO's In Treatment remains TV's most satisfyingly cerebral drama simply by talking, over and over, about age-old woes: family, regret, sex, mortality. And Paul's patients echo the four he treated last season: a woman with whom he has a personal history, a confrontational control freak, a troubled student with a secret and a bitterly fighting married couple. But like a successful patient, the show has learned and grown, becoming more reliably compelling. ...

Read the rest here. The one drawback to the new season so far is that there doesn't seem to be a single patient who's an amazing revelation like Sophie (Mia Wasikowska) last year. But there are also no clunkers like Laura or the squabbling couple from last season; Paul's four cases are solidly engrossing across the board. I'm told (though I haven't watched the originals to confirm) that where as last season practically literally translated the Israeli original, Be'Tipul, this season is more of an adaptation. Maybe that helped, or maybe the writers, American and Israeli, simply learned from experience. 

 

By the way, old fans should be aware that the running schedule has changed this year: The first two "sessions" air Sundays at 9 p.m. E.T., the last three (including Paul's with Gina) Mondays at 9. How do you feel about the change? Personally, I watched all of season one on screeners, but I could see the appeal, especially last year, of being able to more easily cherrypick certain patients (although you lose something of the overall experience that way). On the bright side, I don't find myself wanting to skip any of the patients this year.

  • Print
  • Comment
Comments (2)
Post a Comment »
  • 1

    Last season my cable company had them all On Demand by monday night so I'd be able to just watch at my own pace rather than catching one a day. The new schedule looks like they switched to a more DVR-friendly mode, so people can watch in that fashion.

    Makes no real sense to portion it out a day at a time. It's HBO, if I'm paying for it, why would they care exactly when I watch it?

    Glad to be hearing good things about the new season. The commercial made it look really hammy. I guess if you take a show that's almost all talk and boil it down to the most dramatic 30 seconds, that's what you get.

  • 2

    I get fairly frustrated any time I hear about this program. I love HBO shows and there are a ton of talented people involved in this show, but it perpetuates misconceptions about psychotherapy. For generations, therapy was exactly what is depicted in this show. Unfortunately, this remains the case today as well.

    At the same time, clinical psychology has advanced as a science and there are now not only systematic ways to assess individuals for mental illness, but also empirically supported treatments for many of those illnesses. There's no reason for somebody to be in therapy for years at a time and to simply go into an office and "talk." Cognitive behavioral therapy and other empirically supported treatments are time-limited, solution oriented, extremely effective, and capable of limiting risk of relapse.

    There's nothing wrong with depicting this type of therapy - I simply hate that there are no popular programs out there that make individuals aware of the effective, science-based treatments that are available.

    http://www.psychotherapybrownbag.com

Add Your Comment:

You must be logged in to post a comment.
Tuned In Daily E-mail

Get e-mail updates from TIME's Tuned In in your inbox and never miss a day.

Quotes of the Day »

Get & Share
TAREQ AND MICHAELE SALAHI, a climbing socialite couple from Virginia, in a joint Facebook post, after having allegedly crashed the Obamas' first state dinner without an invite

Stay Connected with TIME.com