A blog about television by TIME’s TV critic James Poniewozik.

Breaking Bad Watch: I Do Not Have Time For a Breaking Bad Watch Edition

Sorry. Just caught up with the episode and must needs prepare for NBC day. So just one nonspoilery thought on another excellent episode in a thus-far great season of Breaking Bad

One idea that's come up in the Great Saving Chuck debate recently is the idea that Chuck is worth saving because it is, unlike many critics' favorites, a pleasure to watch. As Linda Holmes put it on an NPR blog:

Here, critics find themselves passionately advocating for something that's extraordinarily enjoyable to watch. It's like being a dentist who's in the position of telling people entirely truthfully, "You know what's really, really, REALLY good for your teeth? Gummi bears!"

It's a great line. But I don't buy it. I think there's a kind of self-loathing streak in critics that makes us refer to shows that we love as "homework." But I just don't think that's true. I don't watch a show like Friday Night Lights, or The Wire, or Mad Men, because I think I have a moral duty to. I don't do it to improve myself. I don't believe it will unclog my arteries or forestall Alzheimer's. I watch the shows I watch—even the cult, critic-fave ones—because they give me pleasure. Why the hell else would I? Life is too short. 

And I'd cite Breaking Bad as a case in point. Yes, the show has a dismal premise. Yes, it can be ugly and disturbing. But it's also very, very funny, as the entire extended story between the stranded Walt and Jesse showed. And when you look at the musical montage of the two guys cooking meth in the trailer—the thick smoke, the blue crystal, the sunsets—what a gorgeous, gorgeous piece of video. About two guys making drugs in the desert. Call me a bad person, but it just makes me happy (even when it makes me sad). 

Of course that's me. I also prefer Twix bars to gummi bears.

  • Print
  • Comment
Comments (2)
Post a Comment »
  • 1

    Agreed. There are only two shows I make a point to watch live every week, not later on DVR -- Lost and Breaking Bad. I probably laughed out loud more last night than I did watching any show labeled a comedy in the last few weeks. This episode reminded me a little of the "Pine Barrens" episode of the Sopranos, when Christopher and Paulie were lost in the woods. Like Breaking Bad, that series was classified as a serious Sunday night drama, but it was one of the three or four funniest shows on TV for most of its run.
    .
    Also: Funyuns are awesome.

  • 2

    The real distinction to me is shows that require the brain switch to be turned to the on position and those that don't necessarily. I can multitask while watching something like The Mentalist (in fact, I have to, or even Simon Baker's smile and vests would never get me through an hour) or, sorry, Chuck. But I need to be in the right frame of mind to watch Breaking Bad or The Wire, where I can devote my full attention, both because I want to (so much of the pleasure of them is in the details) and because I have to (they're hard to follow if you miss something).

Add Your Comment:

You must be logged in to post a comment.
Tuned In Daily E-mail

Get e-mail updates from TIME's Tuned In in your inbox and never miss a day.

Quotes of the Day »

Get & Share
PAULA DEEN, Food Network chef, who was hit in the face by a ham while volunteering at an Atlanta food drive

Stay Connected with TIME.com