A blog about television by TIME’s TV critic James Poniewozik.

The Morning After: Buy It In Bulk

ABC

ABC

I highly recommend everyone go read Choire Sicha's outstanding op-ed in the New York Times this morning about product placement in America, which among other notes that the film version of The Road even managed to work a plug for VitaminWater into a movie about the Apocalypse. (The Coca-Cola scene he mentions, by the way, was actually in Cormac McCarthy's novel, but who says movies can't improve on books?)

Why do I mention this? Because I have no idea whether Costco paid for its storyline in last night's Modern Family, but if not, it was one of the great freebies in recent memory.

Short version: Cameron drags Mitchell to Costco; Mitchell looks down his nose at it but is quickly smitten by its big-box charms. Now, as Mrs. Tuned In can tell you, I can get as swept away on a Costco binge as anyone. (Four words: fifteen pound strip loin.) But the halo the show hung on the bulk retailer was unsettling even to me—or rather, it would have been, if the plot hadn't also served so well to define the relationship between the two men, while giving us background on their cultural differences and how they met.

And Cameron may have passed Phil as the show's breakout character this week ("I'm like Costco. I'm big and I'm fancy and I dare you to not like me"). If the twin forces of Tivo and Hulu mean more product placements on my TV in the future, I hope they're all as well done as this one. Meanwhile, the episode as a whole showed a lot of promise by demonstrating the ways different combinations of the extended family can play off each other. I'm ready to buy the family-sized container of this one.

  • Print
  • Comment
Comments (11)
Post a Comment »
  • 1

    It's Always Sunny used Dave & Buster's very well last week, and the product placement sort of fit in with the episode's theme of doing whatever it takes in a recession. PP works better shows have fun and crack jokes about the product (there was a line about how it's the best place to get a steak where there's also an arcade).

    I love Modern Family, too. Cougar Town is nice enough but suffers greatly by comparison. I think I've been ruined by the moc-doc/improv sitcoms like Modern Fam, The Office, Park & Rec and Curb, because now everything else seems like it's trying way too hard to sell the jokes. Am I a sitcom snob?

  • 2

    Speaking of product placements, It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia had a great one for Dave & Busters last week. It was more or less mocking D&B while being sponsored by them.

    Of course, nothing can match the Burger King placement on Arrested Development. That will remain the gold standard.

  • 3

    [...] we're on the subject of product placement this morning, I'm going to go out on a limb and guess that Chipotle did not pay for their prominent [...]

  • 4

    If it doesn't turn the fiction into a long commercial, then a piece should have a little product placement, if it can be integrated smoothly into the show or film. If it can be made part of the plot or if it is in character for a fictional being to be drinking or eating that product. Also identifiers of our real lives indicate that the characters live in a universe if not exactly like then pretty close to our own universe. It makes the characters relatable, sometimes the art more effective, if their is commentary on our actual society, and says that maybe this crazy sitcom situation may not be so crazy and that it can actually happen in the real world. Like yesterday's Modern Family, you could totally imagine a snob shopper becoming a warehouse store addict.

    Actually, that seemed the most cliched part of the show. Hasn't that been done before? The funny did come from the two talking to the camera (Casablanca!) but most of it belonged to the other stories, especially the talking session between unlikely siblings. The kid who plays Manny and the kid who plays Brick in The Middle--which is turning into a pleasant surprise-- do superlative, hilarious work.

  • 5

    The thing that makes me like this show so much is how well done each character is, there are no bland characters, and they're doing a good job focusing enough on most of them to develop them fully. Cameron and Phil definitely are the stars so far. The entire gym class scene last week was pure gold. "Everyone loves the Cam Show, its appointment viewing!" I agree that Phil didn't shine as much this week, but he was pretty funny towards the end "I was in a plane craaaaash"

  • 6

    I guess Im not sure who this show is aimed at; I had heard some good things here and elsewhere, but I tuned in (no pun intended) for a good chunk of the show and really didnt find anything I thought was very funny or entertaining.
    So.. who IS it aimed at?

  • 7

    My only criticism is that Phil is that he IS Andy Bernard. Not similar, not influenced by, but the exact same freaking character. Even the quirks in his voice. It's the same exact character.

    Other than that though the show is really really good. And I didn't even think of Costco as product placement until I read this, which I guess speaks to how well it was done.

    BTW the Always Sunny crew is upset that the commercials for D&B ran during the show. That wasn't part of the plan.

    • 7.1

      Interesting. Not only did they play regular ads but it even said "It's Always Sunny is brought to you by Dave & Busters" with the D&B logo plastered to the backdrop right before the break. Seems to me that D&B missed the point of product placement. You are not supposed to rub people's noses in it. Although the placement in Sunny wasn't exactly subtle, it is better to leave the placement unsaid. Instead you get a giant sign saying "YES, we paid for that placement!" If there'd been a big Costco ad during Modern Family it would have been really jarring, distracting you from the show.

Add Your Comment:

You must be logged in to post a comment.
Tuned In Daily E-mail

Get e-mail updates from TIME's Tuned In in your inbox and never miss a day.

Quotes of the Day »

Get & Share
ESFANDIAR RAHIM-MASHAIE, Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad's head of staff, after five British sailors were detained for drifting into Iranian waters

Stay Connected with TIME.com